My take on ‘Why Clojure?’

Both homoiconic nature and functional side make clojure very distinctive language. They are both inherent in making clojure what it is and i would not take one before the other.

As we have blog posts covering the reasons for FP here i’m going to take FP as a paradigm more or less granted in this post.

Why do i see clojure as a great language in the context of functional programming?

Learning and unlearning

First of all it’s hard to learn a programming paradigm in a language that does not embrace it. A wrong tool drives you to make wrong choices. It leaves you without actually learning the paradigm. It is by far the best thing to do to learn a paradigm using tools meant for it. Eric Normand wrote a good blog post about this problem.

To understand the benefits of FP, you have to use languages meant for it. Languages like Haskell (and by extension Elm and Purescript), Clojure, F#, Scala, Other lisps, Erlang, or OCaml.

I take it that you’re not interested in why not Haskell family, F# or OCaml, but i’ll anyhow go through that part. Most of these languages have very limited use in actual business right now. Currently Haskell and OCaml don’t have any place in programming for business. Which is a pity and no fault of the languages . Elm is currently used in front end and as such is still lacking in backend. Purescript seems to be the most versatile and available of these. It works well both in front and on node.js making it a viable language used in professional fullstack dev.

Scala then is a very solid language running on an widely accepted platform: the JVM. It is a very good all around language, there is no doubt about that. It also has a very good yet complex type system. System that can guide a good FP programmer to discover things about their domain. There are yet few things making it lacking in comparison to Clojure.

  1. Main problem in learning is unlearning. The familiar look of Scala drives people to not learn it. It’s easy to hack something with it but actually using Java with different syntax. Learning first Clojure leads to faster understanding of Scala itself. Adding to this rudimentaries of Haskell helps even more. Learn You a Haskell for Great Good! is a good resource for this.
  2. The unique way of thinking about problems and the language that describes them. This way of thinking is very valid and a good tool to learn for any programmer. Biggest reason for this is the homoiconic nature of the language. The great ability it brings in metaprogramming.
  3. Scala is currently only viable for backend use. Unlike scala Clojure has many supported platforms. It supports JVM, JS including node and browser, and CLR. All which acceptable platforms for business use. This makes it possible to share the same code in front end and backend. With it you can make a consistent whole. Creating front end components that are in sync with their microservice counterparts. In scala this is not possible as Scala.js is lacking in actual production grade stability.

So yes scala is an interesting language but not the best to learn FP. Especially so for Java developers.

Motivation as a driver for effectiveness

It’s actually quite hard to have valid measurements for coder efficiency. Yet one thing we do know. Study after study has found that developer motivation is elemental to productivity.

With unenthustiastic devs its best to inspire them. One of the main benefits comes from the fact that clojure is easy to use and makes coding actually fun again. This is a quote you do hear quite a lot from clojure devs.

As this is about inspiring people, you should go with what is good and nice and feels good and brings joy to you. As then you’ll be more inspiring.

Final words

It also goes down to the provable fact that Imperative Paradigm is more complex than simpler FP. Inside FP clojure is a very very very easy way to learn it. Much easier one to reap the rewards than most others.

If you have a bunch of coders struggling with imperative stuff. And you want to get the benefits of FP as fast as possible. Clojure is the fastest one to learn.